New Buffalo Vacation Rentals

Pick your dates to get the best price options.

Select dates
Guests
2 guests

Adults:

2

Children:

0

Child’s age:

List
Map

Best New Buffalo Vacation Rentals

Staying in a vacation rental in New Buffalo allows guests to enjoy the comforts of home while being minutes from stunning beaches and city attractions. Visitors can easily explore local sites, including the nearby lighthouse and lush parks.

5.9

Good

(470 Reviews)

+ 49 photos

Baymont By Wyndham New Buffalo

18800 Harbor Country Drive
Wi-Fi
Free parking
24-hour reception
Snack bar
Indoor swimming pool
Business center
Pets allowed
No smoking on site
Show more + Show less -
Baymont By Wyndham offers comfortable accommodations with essential amenities, providing guests with a smooth stay in New Buffalo. Each of the 54 rooms includes a flat-screen cable TV and coffee-making facilities, while select rooms feature spa baths. Enjoy the heated indoor pool or work out in the fitness center. Guests can take advantage of the snack bar and 24-hour front desk service. Located just 5 minutes from the Four Winds Casino, convenience is a key highlight of this rental.

Price comparison

Average Price 64 US$

8.4

Good

(254 Reviews)

+ 97 photos

Holiday Inn Express & Suites New Buffalo, Mi By Ihg

11500 Holiday Drive
Wi-Fi
Free parking
24-hour reception
Fitness center
Indoor swimming pool
Jacuzzi
Flat-screen TV
Elevator
Business center
No pets allowed
Air conditioning
No smoking on site
Show more + Show less -
Holiday Inn Express & Suites offers contemporary rooms equipped with air conditioning and private bathrooms. Guests can enjoy a complimentary breakfast that includes fresh pastries and fruits each morning. The hotel features a fitness center and an indoor pool for relaxation. Located within minutes from local attractions such as St. Julian Winery and the Hesston Steam Museum, the property is perfect for both leisure and business travelers.

Price comparison

Average Price 299 US$

7.7

Good

(133 Reviews)

+ 74 photos

Fairfield Inn & Suites New Buffalo

11400 Holiday Drive
Wi-Fi
Free parking
24-hour reception
Fitness center
Indoor swimming pool
Laundry
Flat-screen TV
Elevator
Business center
Wheelchair access
No pets allowed
Air conditioning
No smoking on site
Show more + Show less -
Located by Interstate 94, Fairfield Inn & Suites provides easy access to major attractions. Guests can enjoy a daily continental breakfast along with free Wi-Fi and a fitness center. Each room is equipped with a microwave and refrigerator for added convenience. Just a short drive from the Indiana Dunes National Lakeshore and the Lighthouse Place Premium Outlets, this property is ideal for shoppers and nature seekers alike.

Price comparison

Average Price 84 US$

8.0

Good

(653 Reviews)

+ 85 photos

Quality Inn Near Interstate I94

18830 Harbor Country Road
Wi-Fi
Free parking
24-hour reception
24-hour security
Picnic area/ Tables
Fitness center
Indoor swimming pool
Flat-screen TV
Elevator
Business center
VIP check-in/ -out
Golf course
Sun loungers
Cribs
Wheelchair access
No pets allowed
Air conditioning
No smoking on site
Show more + Show less -
Quality Inn offers a family-friendly environment with numerous amenities such as an indoor heated pool and exercise room. Located less than a mile from Lake Michigan, guests have access to a range of recreational activities. Nearby attractions include the Grand Beach Municipal Golf Course and several local shopping options. Free high-speed internet and complementary daily newspapers complete the experience at this convenient location.

Price comparison

Average Price 74 US$

9.0

Good

(82 Reviews)

+ 97 photos

New Buffalo Inn

231 East Buffalo Street
Wi-Fi
Free parking
Baggage storage
Shuttle service
Jacuzzi
Flat-screen TV
Adults only
Dryer
Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
Express check-in/ -out
No pets allowed
Air conditioning
No smoking on site
Show more + Show less -
New Buffalo Inn caters to adults seeking a cozy retreat, offering comfortable accommodations that include a hot tub, sauna, and private bathrooms. Located only minutes from New Buffalo Beach, guests can relax or explore nearby attractions such as the New Buffalo Township Library and Fenway Gallery. Each room comes equipped with kitchenettes for self-catering options. High cleanliness standards and relaxing facilities make this rental particularly appealing.

Price comparison

Average Price 189 US$

8.8

Good

(48 Reviews)

+ 41 photos

Walking Distance To Beach And Shops

619 East Buffalo Street
Free Wi-Fi in rooms
Free parking
Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
Air conditioning
Flat-screen TV
VIP check-in/ -out
Ski equipment rental
Ski school
Ski storage
Hiking
Cycling
Canoeing
Fishing
Horseback riding
Golf course
Outdoor dining area
Picnic area/ Tables
Beach access
Children's play area
Kids club
Playpen
Cribs
Board games
Pets allowed
No smoking on site
Show more + Show less -
Walking Distance To Beach And Shops is a spacious holiday home with three bedrooms, accommodating up to six guests. It features a fully equipped kitchen, an outdoor fireplace, and a lovely garden perfect for gatherings. Situated within walking distance of New Buffalo Beach, visitors can easily access local dining and shopping options. This rental is particularly suitable for families looking for a comfortable and convenient stay.

Price comparison

Average Price 424 US$

New Buffalo Rentals on the Beach

Rentals situated on the beach offer unparalleled access to Lake Michigan's shoreline and recreational activities. Visitors can enjoy a tranquil atmosphere while exploring local attractions like the nearby Galien River County Park.

+ 5 photos

The Harbor Grand Hotel

111 W Water St
Free internet access
Free parking
Indoor swimming pool
Spa & wellness center
Children's play area
Show more + Show less -
The Harbor Grand Hotel provides stunning views of Lake Michigan, just a 5-minute walk from the beach. This boutique-style property features an indoor pool and a wellness area for relaxation. Guests can enjoy nearby attractions, including Galien River Kayaking & Stand-Up Paddleboarding and the full-service Oselka's Snug Harbor Marina. Also, the hotel is conveniently located near Beachside Scoops for dining options.

Price comparison

Average Price 109 US$

8.0

Good

(653 Reviews)

+ 85 photos

Quality Inn Near Interstate I94

18830 Harbor Country Road
Wi-Fi
Free parking
24-hour reception
24-hour security
Picnic area/ Tables
Fitness center
Indoor swimming pool
Flat-screen TV
Elevator
Business center
VIP check-in/ -out
Golf course
Sun loungers
Cribs
Wheelchair access
No pets allowed
Air conditioning
No smoking on site
Show more + Show less -
Quality Inn offers a family-friendly environment with numerous amenities such as an indoor heated pool and exercise room. Located less than a mile from Lake Michigan, guests have access to a range of recreational activities. Nearby attractions include the Grand Beach Municipal Golf Course and several local shopping options. Free high-speed internet and complementary daily newspapers complete the experience at this convenient location.

Price comparison

Average Price 74 US$

7.7

Good

(133 Reviews)

+ 74 photos

Fairfield Inn & Suites New Buffalo

11400 Holiday Drive
Wi-Fi
Free parking
24-hour reception
Fitness center
Indoor swimming pool
Laundry
Flat-screen TV
Elevator
Business center
Wheelchair access
No pets allowed
Air conditioning
No smoking on site
Show more + Show less -
Located by Interstate 94, Fairfield Inn & Suites provides easy access to major attractions. Guests can enjoy a daily continental breakfast along with free Wi-Fi and a fitness center. Each room is equipped with a microwave and refrigerator for added convenience. Just a short drive from the Indiana Dunes National Lakeshore and the Lighthouse Place Premium Outlets, this property is ideal for shoppers and nature seekers alike.

Price comparison

Average Price 84 US$

Known for its picturesque views along Lake Michigan, New Buffalo combines vibrant coastal charm with rich history. Originally established in the early 1800s, this community features local attractions such as the New Buffalo Railroad Museum and is just a short drive from the Indiana Dunes State Park, home to diverse wildlife and scenic landscapes. New Buffalo's accommodations are strategically located for easy access to the beach and various local attractions. With options including beautiful beachside houses and cozy inns, visitors can find top-rated rentals such as Baymont Inn and Fairfield Inn & Suites.

Need inspiration?

View our hand-picked destinations